If there’s one statement in the music Industry that I KNOW is true it’s this one: “Anyone who enters a battle of the bands has already lost”. You name the competition and I’ll guarantee the only ones benefiting from it are the promoters.
The whole concept of an artist competing with other artists is just insane. That’s why they’re called arts and not sports. But in America we love our sports and have to try and make a sport out of everything. But the arts are the most extreme form of apples and oranges you can try to judge. Let’s examine my rant:
You pick them:
Bob Dylan vs. Bob Marley
The Beatles vs. Metallica
Renoir vs. Picasso
Jimi Hendrix vs. Hank Williams
Monet vs. Patrick Nagel
M.C. Hammer vs. Fred Astaire
Gene Krupa vs. John Bonham
Cher vs. Lady Gaga (ok I just wanted to reference Lady Gaga)
But do you get my point? You can’t say Jimi is a better guitar player than Hank Williams. As Eddie Van Halen once said in a response to an acusation by Eric Clapton: “He’s right I don’t play blues. I speak a different language.” It’s wrong to compare art. The better question is to ask is: “Is it art”? (Usually followed by: “You paid how much for that”?) Which leads to; What is art? Only history will decide.
I’m sorry, I get ticked off when I get emails from the ITC. (international Songwriting Contest) or the John Lennon songwriters contest. Give me a break.
I just loath it. I’m sorry.